Sam Buentello Insurance Agency

Amee SaBellaLocal Guide

Apr 20, 2026

I’ve had a great experience working with Andrew to move my business insurance over. After issues with my previous broker, I didn’t expect much—but Andrew and his team completely changed that. He’s been responsive, helpful, and patient with all of my questions. Even when he wasn’t available, someone else stepped in quickly to help. I requested several quote changes, and everything was handled promptly, with clear explanations each time. Working with Sam Buentello Insurance Agency has been a breath of fresh air. I never feel like I’m bothering them, and I trust that anything I need will be handled quickly and correctly. I’ve already referred them to others and will continue to do so.

Wendi BeckLocal Guide

Apr 12, 2026

We’ve been a customer of Sam Buentello Insurance Agency for a few years now, and so happy we made the switch. Insurance rates around the country are ridiculously high yet Carrie continues to find a way to save us money. She’s been a lifeline for us during an especially difficult time for us and we couldn’t be more thankful for her time & efforts.

Joe BonckowskiLocal Guide

Mar 24, 2026

Sam and the team have been fantastic to work with over the years! You are not just number to them, they actually care and are helpful. I look forward to many more years working together with them for all my insurance needs!

John CaponeLocal Guide

Apr 23, 2026

Carrie Washington is our go-to for all our questions and requests. She is always very responsive, friendly, and professional.

Zacharia VargheseLocal Guide

Oct 15, 2025

Fast, responsive, asked the right questions gave us a great commercial property insurance deal.

Michael Walker

Oct 15, 2025

Carrie made the whole process of insurance for a large 5th wheel RV and a Ford F550 to pull it very painless. In my 60 years of working with insurance companies Carrie is the very best agent we have experience. Thanks for making this potential bad experience into a pleasant one.